Make A One-Time Payment

Wayne PolicyPlus allows you to manage your policies online.  When you enroll, you can make payments online quickly and easily.  However, if you prefer to make a payment without logging in, we offer the following options:

Pay online

Online bill pay offers a quick, easy way for you to make a payment.

Click on the button below and enter your policy number and ZIP code.  You will have the option to pay by credit/debit card or directly from your checking account.

Make A Payment

Pay by phone*

Call the Wayne Insurance Group at (800) 222-3873 to pay by credit card or check-by-phone.
*Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.


Please list your policy number on your check and send to:

Wayne Insurance Group
P.O. Box 1735
Wooster, OH 44691

Wayne Insurance Group

For more than a century, the Wayne Insurance Group companies have delivered financial security and peace of mind for families, farms and businesses. As mutual insurance companies, we exist to serve the insurance needs of our policyholders. We have partnered with a network of independent agents to offer a full line of insurance programs backed by prompt, fair claims service and support.

Contact Us

Wayne Insurance Group
3873 Cleveland Road
Wooster, Ohio 44691

Tel: 330-345-8100 | Tol: 800-222-3873

Wayne Mutual Insurance Company

Founded in 1910, Wayne Mutual Insurance Company provides a wide range of property and casualty insurance programs for automobiles, homes, farms, investment properties, and businesses.

Washington Mutual Insurance Association

Since 1878, Washington Mutual Insurance Association has provided protection for homes, farms and personal property. Our products can be tailored to meet the specific needs of our policyholders.